radiant barrier frequently asked questions, energy conservation, attic insulation, sustainable products, radiant barrier, radient barrier, photovoltaics, Extreme make over home edition, Home Depot, APS, SRP
Radiant Barrier Chips for cold climates Thermal Control Membrane for hot climates
What is radiant heat?
Radiant heat is heat that is radiated from a heat source through space (with or without air). The heat from the sun is radiant heat. Most of the heat from a bright light bulb is radiant heat. Radiant heat is also called infra-red heat or infra-red energy.
What is infra-red energy?
Infra-red energy is electromagnetic energy that is not visible. It is next to red in the light wavelength spectrum. It travels at the speed of light (186,000 miles per second), until it hits a surface (like your home). This stopping of the energy source excites the molecules in the wall which starts to conduct the heat towards inside (during the summer).
When infra-red energy is traveling through air, a very small portion of the energy is absorbed by molecules in the air.
How does heat move?
Heat moves by conduction, convection, and radiation.
Conduction is the process that occurs in substances denser than air like water and wood and stone where the heat moves through the substance. Conduction occurs rapidly in metals like gold and copper and very slowly in an insulation like fiberglass.
Convection is the process where air makes contact with substances that are conducting heat and the air is heated. Hot air rises and this movement makes room for cooler air and the process continues until the air and the surfaces are close to the same temperature
Radiation is the process of the infra-red energy emitting from the heated substance through space. The energy travels in a straight line at the speed of light until it is absorbed or reflected by another substance. It is important to remember that in order for heat to move by radiation, there must be space between the objects. The space can be as small as a few air molecules and still be effective. If the objects are touching, then the heat moves by conduction, not be radiation.
What is reflectivity?
Reflectivity, for radiant barrier purposes, can be defined as a measure of how much of the energy is reflected and not absorbed by the barrier. Very shiny aluminized plastic can reflect 98% of the radiant heat that strikes it.
What is absorptivity? Absorptivity, for radiant barrier purposes, can be defined as a measure of how much of the energy is not reflected and is absorbed by the material.
What is emissivity?
Emissivity is the ability for radiant heat to emit from a surface. The higher the emissivity, the faster radiant heat is emitted. Very shiny aluminized plastic only emits about 4% of the heat absorbed radiantly and also from the hot air around it. This is why pot belly stoves are flat black, so they will freely emit radiant heat. For comparison, unpainted wood has an e value of .95 making it an excellent emitter (that's why insulation gets so hot). Polished gold (the lowest e value), has an e factor of .02 and be seen on the face shields of space helmets.
What kind of materials are used to make radiant
Aluminum foils are one common material. Our proprietary products use a new type of plastic radiant barrier made possible by successful research into making a lighter weight radiant barrier for spacecraft. The process is called vacuum deposition technology and it makes it possible to put a very, very thin deposit of aluminum on a film substrate. Independent testing of this metalized film returned the lowest emissivity of any reflective membrane: .02.
After the summer sun goes down, where is the hottest
place in the attic?
Most people (architects, builders even engineers), quickly comment that the hottest place in the attic is up near the center of the roof. Heat rises right? Sure, heat rises but radiant travels at 186,000 miles per second in a straight line from the emitting source. For this example (since we are talking about houses), it would be the roof deck. So, if radiant heat is being emitted from the roof deck towards the insulation where does it stop? The insulation. Care to venture a guess now where the hottest spot is in the attic?
The top couple of inches of the insulation! Fact is, 1" below the insulation can be as much as 20F to 30F degrees hotter than the hottest air you can measure anywhere in the attic...including up near the peak. And it remains the hottest thing in the attic until the next morning when the sun begins its radiant heating again. It is easy to comprehend when we consider that the insulation has been absorbing radiant heat all day long, and now it is resisting that heat is trying to leave into the cooler attic air.
In the attic, where is the best place to install
One problematic technique is to put radiant barrier directly on the underside of the roof sheeting. What happens in any attic that is not extremely well ventilated is that the surface of the radiant barrier gets very hot and the heat is conducted and convected into the air of the attic causing the attic and its insulation to get quite hot. Then once the sun goes down and the heat wants to radiate out of the insulation, it is reflected back by the radiant barrier trapping this unwanted heat for hours. To see the results of this type of application, click here.
Further, any application of radiant barrier up at the roof deck has little or no savings or impact on comfort during winter months. One other consideration is the overheating of shingles and tile underlayment. Replacing dried out tile underlayment is a very expensive proposition. Shingle manufacturers are now limiting or voiding warranties where RBS is installed under the roof decking.
So, the only logical location left is on top of the insulation. Here, the radiant barrier does the bulk of its work by preventing the infra-red energy from being absorbed by the porous insulation. The radiant barrier gets hot because it is a poor emitter and it conducts and convects the heat to the cooler air at the floor of the attic. The air rises and can leave at any attic vent and does not have to be controlled like the aforementioned method. Only the RBS Chips save you energy everyday of the year and carries a lifetime performance warranty. One problem with rolling out a reflective membrane on top of the insulation is the accumulation of dust on the top surface. Click here for a more detailed explanation.
How important is attic ventilation with an attic
radiant barrier system? Ventilation is very important because this is the
primary method used to get rid of the heat that is being stopped by the radiant
barrier. In climates that require a lot of cooling, it is recommended that
attic ventilation at the top of the attic meet or exceed the Uniform Building
Code recommendations of 1/150th of the attic area. The UBC also specifies
1/600th at the eaves/soffits of the roof. It is recommended that this be at
least 1/200th of the attic area. The UBC's attic ventilation requirements are
directed toward preventing moisture condensation problems but they are equally
valuable to hot climate homes that need to get rid of the heat absorbed by the
roof. It is the opinion of this site that venting codes are not sufficient
for hot climates as they are designed for moisture egress, not sufficient
exhausting of super heated air.
Isn't it difficult to install radiant barrier in an
Stapling up sheets of radiant barrier is very difficult to install in existing attics and as can be seen in this test, an incorrect application. It is also difficult to get a good installation because of the difficult working conditions of extreme heat in the summer, low headroom, numerous roof framing or truss webs in the way, and low light conditions. Our TCM product comes in small, easy to use rolls and simply rolls out over your existing insulation. Click here to see a short video of how it's done.
What is the "Achilles Heel" of radiant barrier?
One must know one's strengths and one's weaknesses! Think about this. What makes a mirror not reflect well? Dirt! It is the same for radiant barrier so when dust collects on the upward-facing highly reflective surface of the radiant barrier, it then has a very low reflectivity and is now a very good absorber. Now only the downward-facing low emissivity surface is left to do the work. All of our patented RBS products have multiple layers which insure dust accumulation on the top layer does not degrade the performance...forever.
One of our competitors has this on their web page:
Q. What about using "foil chips" in my attic ? Wouldn't that be just as good as laying down your product on my existing insulation ?
A. No. One company claims their product performs better than other RB products and is not subjected to such problems as dust on the surface affecting its performance and claim their product would not trap moisture, where others products would. Because there is no regulation of what people say on web pages, the consumer is at the mercy of the advertiser. You need to demand that the seller provide you with acceptable test data on their product, not someone else's! You need to protect yourself so you don't get ripped off. Compare and don't be taken in by false claims. For example, all RB products installed in attics must have a flame spread rating of 25 or less according to UBC(Uniform Building Code). That means the supplier must be able to provide you with a copy of this test if you request it. When in doubt make them supply documentation!
Fact is, both RBS Chips and Thermal Control
Membrane have a lifetime, transferable performance warranty. Before
buying any RBS, make sure you get a performance warranty in writing.
As for the fire rating, RBS chips have a class III fire rating as
specified on the material data safety sheet supplied by the manufacturer.
This rating means RBS chips will burn but will not give off toxic fumes or
smoke. Keep this in mind: In a 2000 square foot home only 66lbs of RBS
chips are used. That's 1056 ounces spread out over 2000 square feet or a
little over a half ounce per square foot. There simply is not enough mass
(fuel) to make this an issue. To further prove this, in December of 2002
one of the homes that had RBS Chips installed had an attic fire due to a bad
connection without an electrical box. The old cellulose insulation caught
fire and the homeowner observed this and put it out with a fire extinguisher.
When asked if the RBS Chips appeared to contribute the fire he said "no".
Is there a way to avoid dust in attics?
No. There is no practical way to keep an attic dust free so the challenge for radiant barriers is to work well in spite of the dust. As a matter of fact, a radiant barrier system is not designed to work with dust is not worth considering. Some studies seem to be finding that some types of dusty radiant barrier are worse than no radiant barrier at all.
Well, then if the attic floor is the best place for
radiant barrier but dust makes it not work, and it is difficult to install, what
are my options?
These challenges were the catalyst to the invention of a new kind of radiant barrier called EcoGuard Radiant Barrier Chips (click here) and Thermal Control Membrane (click here). Chips are made from aluminized plastic film that is manufactured into small pieces. Then to install it, a lightweight blower and hose is employed to blow a coating of chips on top of the existing insulation. The radiant barrier becomes a topcoat to the insulation, the "icing on the cake" that makes a complete insulation. This same engineering principle was used to develop our latest product: Thermal Control Membrane (TCM).
Dust is no longer the death-knell because the chips (and TCM), are installed multiple layers deep, which is how a true radiant barrier is made. The layer exposed to dust becomes ineffective on the dusty side but all the rest keep doing their job. Tim Carter, syndicated columnist and building expert has had RBS Chips in his home for over a year. Here's what he has to say about it: click here
How about mixing the chips with the insulation and
blowing them in all at once?
Chips must lay on top of each other and mixing fibrous insulation with them would only serve to lower the performance.
What happens if the chips are disturbed?
If the chips are installed on batt insulation, it is very easy to just move them back over the places where the insulation is exposed. When chips are installed on loose-fill insulation and the chips become well mixed with the insulation, it is necessary to thin out the many layers around the disturbed area and use them to cover the exposed insulation.
Do the chips stop the moisture from migrating and cause
No. Because the chips are not one continuos layer but are loose, the moisture trying to leave a warm humid house into a cold attic has no problem getting out. But with continuous, unperforated sheet radiant barriers, moisture condensation has been a real problem in colder climates.
What if the attic is small and there is no way a person
could get in there to blow the chips?
Many times such attics are under-ventilated. With the need for more ventilation, this provides a serendipitous opportunity to cut some small holes in the roof, blow the chips in and then install the attic dormer-shaped vents or adding an extension pipe to the RBS Chip blowing hose.
How about chips and cold climates?
Radiant Barrier Chips work as well in cold climates as it does in hot climates. Much like a Thermos bottle, the reflective coating on the RBS film reflects interior heat back into the room. Our testing has shown ceiling temperatures increase 8f to 10f degrees where the chips are installed. In new homes, radiant barrier can be installed in sheet form, just behind the drywall thus becoming a vapor barrier and a radiant barrier. Reductions up to 47% have been reported and much more comfortable homes.
What is "TCM"
TCM is an acronym for our latest product: "Thermal Control Membrane". TCM is a multi-layered radiant barrier that can be rolled out over existing attic insulation (no dust problem), or stapled to walls in new construction. If used on walls and in the attic of a new home the HVAC sizing must be reduced by at least 30% or the units will short cycle due to the reduced heat gain and heat loss of the home.
For information on our
patented RBS products,
click here to return to our main page.
Click here to return to the Outsulation page.
Click here to contact an application specialist or if you just have questions
Web page design and maintained by B Rad
Copyright 1997-2014 all images, text and HTML copyrighted by Horizon Energy Systems.
All rights reserved and violators will be prosecuted.
Information in this document is subject to change without notice.
Other products and companies referred to herein are
trademarks or registered trademarks of their
respective companies or mark holders.